DEWALT DWE6411 vs DWE6423K vs Makita BO4556 Palm Sander

It’s tough shopping for a power tool, especially a palm sander, because you need to experience how well it works, how much punishment it takes, and what kind of bells and whistles you can expect the manufacturers designed into the product. Along with professional reviews, this has made positive customer reviews increase the likelihood of buying by as much as four times. 

There should be no surprises then that two of the oldest and most innovative companies in the power tools business would come out on top in Amazon customer ratings. DeWalt and Makita are both pioneering brands in power tools as far as the early 20th century with the American brand starting out in 1923 and the Japanese one in 1915.

In this review, we’re putting three of the most highly rated palm sanders in Amazon from both companies to see which one comes out on top. We have two from DeWalt, the DEWALT DWE6411 and the DEWALT DWE6423K, and one from Makita, the BO4556.

Quick Summary

All the sanders we’re reviewing offer good value for money thanks to their powerful motors and user-friendly design. Of course, they have subtle differences that make them ideal for specific users.

The DEWALT DWE6411 will serve the needs of beginners who want a small compact sander that does not sacrifice power for lightness. Women and the elderly have taken a liking to the DEWALT DWE6411 for its portability and its performance.

Woodworkers who want quality in their finishes can opt for the DeWalt DWE6423K. Since it’s a random orbit sander, it won’t leave circular scratch marks on the grains of the wood like a normal orbital sander would.

The Makita BO4556 finishing sander is the lightest sander here at 2.4 lbs. As it combines a light frame, ergonomic handles, and a motor capable of 14,000 orbits per minute, it’s the best partner for carpenters or craftsmen who need to work on a sanding surface for long periods of time.

DEWALT DWE6411 Vs. DWE6423K Vs. Makita BO4556: Three-Way Palm Sander Battle

DEWALT DWE6411

DEWALT Electric Sander, 1/4-Inch Sheet, Orbital (DWE6411)

Power

The DEWALT DWE6411 spins around 14,000 orbits per minute, making sanding easy and efficient. Users can easily restore shine to their old furniture like their old family table with less time than other sanders in the market.

Sandpaper Retention and Change

Unlike some velcro-based fastening systems, the DEWALT DWE6411 uses clamps found at the sides of the machine. Users will just need to leave a little more sandpaper to the sides to maximize the use of the clamps.

Vibration-Free Operation

The DEWALT DWE6411’s casing has an embedded counterweight to absorb the vibrations from the machine. This means there’s less noise and fatigue when users operate the sander for long periods.

What We Like:

  • A plastic plate that came in the kit allows users to perforate sanding papers for easier attachments to the sanding pad.
  • At just around 3 lbs, the sander allows users greater freedom in carrying the machine and enables longer working periods as it needs less strength strain to hold it up.

What We Don’t Like

  • The sander may run into issues with dust collection. Users need to make sure the dust port channels aren’t blocked.

The Solution

If there is a lot of wood dust, users should work with the sander outside and wear masks to avoid any health issues.

DEWALT DWE6423K

DEWALT Random Orbit Sander, 5-Inch (DWE6423K)

Compact Form Factor

Users need to constantly have a good sightline of sanding surfaces and this is sometimes not possible because of some sanders’ big and bulky form factors. The DEWALT DWE6423K saves space through its compact design also allowing for greater work area visibility.

Vibration Elimination

Much like DEWALT DWE6411 the DEWALT DWE6423K also carries a vibration-free design thanks to the inclusion of a counterweight. Since there is less vibration, users will feel less strain on their hands and arms while working on projects, enabling them to apply finishings longer.

Power for Tough Sanding Jobs

Using a 3 amp motor, the DEWALT DWE6423K can work on the tough sanding jobs like fiberglass finishing. Its variable-speed motor can work from 8,000 to 13,000 orbits per minute, making it the ideal partner for prepping surfaces using the lowest speed setting as well.

What We Like:

  • Hook and Loop system for easier removal and replacement of sanding pads. Just remove the sanding paper from the velcro and replace it with a fresh one.
  • This DeWalt sander can take on even punishing sanding jobs. One customer used it to wet grind a concrete countertop for six days without the motor breaking down.
  • Variable speed setting allows users to work surfaces in a variety of ways from removing paints, to prep work and to finally giving projects that nice shine and gloss.

What We Don’t Like

  • Dust port adapter connections may not connect to universal shop vac adapters. 

The Solution

Users can easily retrofit their own adapters. You can use 2-inch or 1-1/2 inch drain and trap adapters to make an attachment that will work.

MAKITA BO4556

Makita BO4556 2 Amp Finishing Sander

Ergonomic Design

A palm sander should feel comfortable even at first grip. Since users will be using this machine for long periods of time, it should minimize strain while keeping the hand in the same position for periods at a time. The MAKITA BO4556’s rubberized grip gives comfort that allows uses to ease into the machine.

Easy Sandpaper Replacement

The extra-large clamps on the MAKITA BO4556 secure sanding papers, keeping them from flying away during sanding operation. This feature gives users peace of mind and safety while sanding since the high amounts of spins sanders do can cause sanding papers to fly off from weaker fastenings.

Single Touch Convenience

MAKITA BO4556’s switch allows you to push it only once and it will stay on so you can work on your projects without having to constantly put your finger on the button. What’s better is the switch comes sealed for protection against sawdust since particles may affect the operation of sanders in general.

What We Like:

  • Lightweight form factor does not trade portability for power as this sander can revolve around 14,000 orbits per minute.
  • Comes with its own easy-to-carry case for better transport and storage.
  • Thanks to its portability and power, this sander serves as the perfect finishing tool for home projects.

What We Don’t Like

  • The dust bag may get in the way of the user’s arms during operation.

The Solution

If the dust bag becomes too much of an annoyance, users should attach a shop vacuum and remove the bag.

DEWALT DWE6411 Vs DWE6423K Vs. MAKITA BO4556: Which is Better?

After comparing notes and testing, we’ve found the DEWALT DWE6423K blows the other two sanders out of the water thanks to its variable speed setting features.

Although the DEWALT DWE6411 practically comes close this orbital sander, the ability to work from as low as 8,000 rpm to 13,000 rpm using the DEWALT DWE6423K, gives woodworkers and home users the flexibility to work at different kinds of sanding jobs.

Although the MAKITA BO4556 is lighter than the DEWALT DWE6423K at around 2.6 pounds, we felt the DEWALT DWE6423K proved to be better at off-setting vibration and reducing noise than the Japanese branded sander.

The DEWALT DWE6423K comes at a premium price point but for its features, it’s battle-tested durability, and the flexibility it gives to its users, we can say it’s a good investment for your money.

Final Thoughts

The best products always rise to the top and the palm sanders we’ve reviewed here only prove this point further. If you’re looking for the best palm sanders in town, go and check Amazon for customer reviews aside from this article.

They’ll clue you in at the best of the best. Customer reviews are also working for the interest of power tools consumers since the manufacturers are listening. Pretty soon, we’ll see more user-friendly power tools out there at a price we’ll love since we assert on features we like and don’t like.